Thu. Jul 11th, 2024

Cat Carrol

By Cat Lovers, for the Cats and Their Owners

Made by Nacho Vs. The Honest Kitchen Comparison in 2023

Made by Nacho and The Honest Kitchen logo

Which one is better? Made By Nacho vs. The Honest Kitchen? How do you know which cat food is best for your little furry friend? In this article, we compare Made By Nacho and The Honest Kitchen, two of the most famous pet food brands, highlighting their fundamental differences.

We’ve used the latest nutritional and price information to compare these two brands comprehensively. When selecting the best pet food brand for your furry friend, several essential factors must be considered, including ingredient quality, product safety, guaranteed analysis, brand history, and cost.

To provide a detailed comparison between The Honest Kitchen and Made By Nacho, we’ve relied on average data to make general comparisons. If you want to read individual product reviews, please take a look at our Made By Nacho cat food review.

The Honest Kitchen vs. Made by Nacho Cat Food

According to AAFCO, all pet food labels must provide a guaranteed analysis of nutrient content. Made By Nacho and The Honest Kitchen is no different. The cat food companies must give the users maximum percentages of crude fiber and moisture and minimum percentages of crude fat and protein. And in this comparison, all percentages are averages that have been given on a dry matter basis.

Made by Nacho vs. The Honest Kitchen Cat Food

Wet / Canned cat foodMade by nachoThe Honest Kitchen
Crude Fat22.1%24.6%
Crude Protein49.1%52.0%
Crude Fiber8.4%5.1%
Dry Cat Food
Crude Fiber4.4%3.5%
Crude Fat20.4%23.1%
Crude Protein35.9%40.4%

Crude protein comparison between Made by Nacho & The Honest Kitchen:

Cats are obligate carnivores, requiring a diet rich in animal-based protein to meet their nutritional needs. Protein is essential for cats as it provides the building blocks for their muscles, tissues, and organs. It is also crucial for producing enzymes, hormones, and antibodies, which help maintain a healthy immune system.

The protein content of Made By Nacho dry recipes is 4.49% lower than that of The Honest Kitchen’s dry recipes, which is a significant difference between the two brands. Regarding wet cat foods, The Honest Kitchen generally offers a slightly higher protein content, approximately 2.94% more than Made By Nacho.

Crude fat comparison:

Cats require a certain amount of fat in their diet to maintain good health. Fat provides a concentrated energy source and plays several essential roles in the body. Fat is vital for absorbing fat-soluble vitamins, such as A, D, E, and K, which are necessary for various bodily functions, including healthy vision, bone development, and blood clotting.

Furthermore, fat helps maintain healthy skin and coat, as it contains fatty acids necessary for skin and coat health. Cats with diets low in fat may develop dry, itchy, or flaky skin, and their coats may become dull or brittle.

Our average data shows that Made By Nacho dry cat food typically contains less fat than The Honest Kitchen. However, the difference in fat content between the two brands is relatively minor, and it may not significantly impact your cat’s health. It’s worth noting that The Honest Kitchen’s wet cat food options tend to have higher fat content than Made By Nacho’s wet foods.

Crude fiber comparison:

Regarding crude fiber content, both brands offer a similar amount. However, in terms of wet cat food options, Made By Nacho tends to contain slightly more fiber, approximately 3.32% higher than the fiber content in The Honest Kitchen’s wet food products.

What type of cat food is better to feed your cat?

Good cat food should provide balanced nutrition that meets your cat’s specific needs. The type of cat food best depends on several factors, including age, weight, activity level, and health status. In general, most cats thrive on high-quality, commercially available cat food that is formulated to meet their nutritional needs.

There are two main types of cat food: dry food (kibble) and wet food (canned). Each type has its advantages and disadvantages.

Dry food is convenient, affordable, and has a long shelf life. It can help maintain dental health by removing plaque and tartar as the cat chews on the kibble. However, some cats may not drink enough water when eating dry food, which can lead to dehydration.

Wet food has a higher moisture content, which can help with hydration and prevent urinary tract problems. It is often more palatable than dry food, making it a good option for picky eaters. However, it is more expensive, spoils quickly, and can contribute to dental problems if the cat doesn’t have access to dental chews or regular teeth cleaning.

The Honest Kitchen pet food ingredients vs. Made by Nacho pet food ingredients

The Honest Kitchen uses controversial ingredients such as dried garlic to prepare cat foods. It is believed that a few specific elements can have adverse health effects. On the other hand, Made by Nacho uses Menadione Sodium Bisulfite, a synthetic version of vitamin K. Such food ingredients can harm cats.

Whether you are feeding The Honest Kitchen or Made by Nacho to your feline, read the ingredients before buying cat foods. According to records, Made By Nacho cat food label has never been recalled, whereas, The Honest Kitchen label has been recalled once.


While choosing cat food, you must consider their nutritional needs, preferences, and underlying health conditions. A balanced and nutritious diet is essential for your cat’s overall health, and the quality of their food plays a significant role in achieving this goal. Made by Nacho and The Honest Kitchen, both labels are famous for their nutritional properties.

It is also essential to avoid foods that contain artificial colors, preservatives, and fillers, which can harm cats’ health. Above brands restrain themselves from using any artificial preservatives. So, choose the right cat food and ensure your cat’s healthy and happy life.

Spread the care